You can never go wrong with cookies no matter the age of the recipient. Additionally, cookies are the perfect gift for any occasion. Best of all, cookies come in different themes, making it easier for you to find cookies that are perfect for the occasion and the age of the recipient. This guide has been created purposefully to inform you about the best places to find mail-order cookies, so you can shop from the comfort of your own home. Read on and decide for yourself where you will order your next batch of mail order cookies!

Top 5 Retailers That Sell Mail-Order Cookies

  • Salty Tart Bakery, Minneapolis, MN
  • Cake Monkey Bakery, Los Angeles, CA
  • Vermont Cookie Love, North Ferrisburgh, VT
  • Buenos Angies, New York, NY
  • Momofuku Milk Bar, New York, NY

Salty Tart Bakery, Minneapolis, MN

Salty Tart Bakery is an awesome and reliable place to order mail order cookies in Minneapolis. The cookies are made to feel like how you expect your homemade cookies to taste. The baker of these cookies also highlights the ingredients used in all the cookies they ship. All cookie orders take place on Mondays, if you want fresh cookies. Thus, ensure that you place your order by 10 am Central Standard time on Mondays only. Deliveries are done via UPS.


  • The owner was named a semi-finalist for the James Beard Outstanding Baker 2016
  • They ship fresh cookies on Mondays
  • Delivery is via a reliable courier service

Cake Monkey Bakery, Los Angeles, CA

The mail order cookies from Cake Monkey come with a whimsical twist to them. They have managed to twist the delicacies from the past into something to enjoy today. The bakery uses an interesting variety of ingredients for their cookies, such as marshmallows and caramelized rice. The company’s selection includes cookies such as Ring Dings, Cakewiches, and the El Rollos. The company has also reinvented Oreo cookies and named them the Big O.


  • They have a huge selection of cookies
  • The cookies are aesthetically pleasing
  • A lot of creativity has gone into creating the cookies

Vermont Cookie Love, North Ferrisburgh, VT

A former New Yorker Paul Seyler started Vermont Cookie Love. Initially, he used to run a high and respected joint in the big apple. He moved his entire family to the town of North Ferrisburg to start his cookie business. The recipes used in this cookies are sourced from locally available materials. The Cookie Love bakery manages to combine the quality of a high-end restaurant with the simplicity of a cookie delivery service.


  • The cookies are made using organic ingredients
  • The company has reviewed rave reviews
  • Their cookies are always out of the oven, made from frozen dough

Buenos Angies, New York, NY

Although these cookies are beloved in the U.S., they are the king of cookies in Argentina. These crumbly cookies made using cornstarch, fresh lemon zest, flour, and milk caramel are quite mouthwatering. The process of creating the perfect Alfarjores is quite complex. However, Buenos Angies have managed it perfectly. These are the most exotic cookies you will find in any bakery in the country.


  • They make exotic cookies
  • They manage to replicate the cookie formula perfectly
  • They have invented their twist to the classic Alfajores for variety

Momofuku Milk Bar, New York, NY

If you order these mail order cookies, you will be quite delighted. The bakery is a partner to the high-end Momokufu restaurants. There are cookies of all shapes and ingredients found at their online store. They have divided their cookies into a number of categories such as Compost Cookies, Milk Bar Cookies, and others. The head baker, Christina Tosi is quite experienced in the cookie industry. She will take you down memory lane with her delicious cookies.


  • They are a perfect way to remember your childhood
  • The head chef is experienced and dedicated to her work
  • There is always a consistency in the quality of cookies delivered


There are many cookies available in mail order stores. However, these five retailers have surpassed expectations and deliver exceptional quality to their clients each and every time. As a result, they have gained a bit of a following online. Read in-depth reviews of any of these cookie stores, and you will be amazed by the quality people claim to have gotten. Try the amazing cookies for yourself with just one click of a button.